1v1 Institutional Counterparty Comparison
CommSec vs Tickmill: Regulation, 6D Ratings & Safety Audit
Deterministic head-to-head benchmarking of CommSec (Commonwealth Securities Limited) and Tickmill (Tickmill UK Limited) across primary regulatory filings, statutory Tier-1 authorisations, 6-Dimension compliance scores, execution software, and warning exposure.
Coverage: Financial institutions headquartered across Singapore, Asia-Pacific, the Middle East and emerging markets
Tickmill outranks CommSec by +0.5 pts in composite 6D scoring (7.0 vs 6.5)
On supervisory breadth, CommSec holds 1 active regulated licence(s) (0 Tier-1) out of 1 total filings and 0 warning count(s), whereas Tickmill holds 4 active regulated licence(s) (0 Tier-1) out of 4 total filings and 1 warning count(s). Allocators should inspect the individual licence numbers and contracting legal entities below before onboarding.
6-Dimension Quantitative Scorecard Comparison
Head-to-head breakdown across all 6 proprietary evaluation dimensions (0.0–10.0 scale).
| Evaluation Dimension | Methodology Weight | CommSec | Tickmill | Score Delta | Dimension Leader |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Composite 6D Score | 100% Composite | 6.5 | 7.0 | +0.5 | Tickmill |
| Regulatory & Licensing Integrity (riskScore) | 30% Weight | 6.5 | 7.0 | +0.5 | Tickmill |
| Execution & Software Infrastructure (industryScore) | 20% Weight | 4.0 | 4.0 | 0.0 | Statistical Tie |
| User Reputation & Complaint Telemetry (userScore) | 20% Weight | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | Statistical Tie |
| Institutional Brand Longevity (brandScore) | 15% Weight | 6.5 | 8.0 | +1.5 | Tickmill |
| Global Market Influence & Footprint (influenceScore) | 15% Weight | 6.5 | 7.0 | +0.5 | Tickmill |
Visual Architecture Benchmark: CommSec vs Tickmill
Vector comparison exhibit generated from live supervisory snapshot metrics.
Regulatory Standing, Entity & Platform Comparison
Structural comparison of supervisory authorisations, domicile, execution terminals, and risk telemetry.
| Audit Attribute | CommSec | Tickmill |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Legal Name | Commonwealth Securities Limited | Tickmill UK Limited |
| Source Risk Classification | Risk level not supplied | Risk level not supplied |
| Active Regulated / Total Filings | 1 regulated / 1 total (0 Tier-1) | 4 regulated / 4 total (0 Tier-1) |
| Recorded Certificate Numbers | ||
| Registered Domicile / Address | Commonwealth Bank Place South' Level 1, 11 Harbour Street, SYDNEY NSW 2000 Commonwealth Securities Locked Bag 22 Australia Square NSW 1215 | 3rd Floor, 27 - 32 Old Jewry, London EC2R 8DQ, England |
| Offered Asset Classes & Services | Australian shares, margin loans, cash, options, ETFs, warrants, fixed income securities, international shares | Foreign exchange, precious metals, crude oil, stock index |
| Execution Software & Terminals | Proprietary / Web Platform | MT4, MT5 |
| Supported Client Languages | English | Chinese (Simplified), English, Italian, Polish, Malay and languages of other countries or regions |
| Warning / Exposure Count | 0 recorded warning(s) | 1 recorded warning(s) |
| Specialized Sub-Page Audits |
Related 1v1 Institutional Comparisons
Compare CommSec and Tickmill against other regulated peers in our financial institutions headquartered across singapore, asia-pacific, the middle east and emerging markets slice.
Frequently Asked Questions: CommSec vs Tickmill
Deterministic counterparty comparison answers derived from supervisory records.
Which institution has stronger regulatory oversight: CommSec or Tickmill?
Tickmill holds more active regulated filings (4 vs 1). Specifically, CommSec maintains 1 total recorded filing(s) (ASIC) with 0 warning flag(s), whereas Tickmill maintains 4 recorded filing(s) (Financial Conduct Authority, FSCA, CYSEC, Financial Services Authority Seychelles) with 1 warning flag(s). Always confirm the specific subsidiary onboarding your account on the official regulator register.
How do the 6D quantitative compliance scores compare between CommSec and Tickmill?
In World Firm Ledger's 6-Dimension scoring matrix (0.0–10.0 scale), CommSec records an Overall Score of 6.5 (Risk & Licensing: 6.5, Brand: 6.5, Market Influence: 6.5, User Reputation: 0.0, Execution & Software: 4.0), compared with Tickmill at 7.0 Overall (Risk & Licensing: 7.0, Brand: 8.0, Market Influence: 7.0, User Reputation: 0.0, Execution & Software: 4.0).
How do CommSec and Tickmill differ in trading platforms and asset classes?
CommSec lists Australian shares, margin loans, cash, options, ETFs, warrants, fixed income securities, international shares with execution software [proprietary/web execution], while Tickmill lists Foreign exchange, precious metals, crude oil, stock index with execution software [MT4, MT5]. Counterparties should verify FIX/API connectivity, server routing topology, and negative balance protection per entity.
Which counterparty carries lower regulatory warning and complaint exposure: CommSec or Tickmill?
CommSec carries a "Risk level not supplied" classification with 0 warning/exposure count(s) and 0 user comment(s), while Tickmill carries a "Risk level not supplied" classification with 1 warning/exposure count(s) and 0 user comment(s).
Structured against supervisory register snapshots and public regulatory filings. Verify your contracting legal entity and current authorisation status directly on the issuing regulator’s official register before transacting.